https://producthunt.com
55of 100
55of 100
“Product Hunt's homepage is a well-oiled content machine that completely forgets it has a conversion job to do.”
The single H1 'Top Products Launching Today' treats every visitor like a returning power user, while the dismissible welcome banner — the only onboarding hook — is one X-click away from oblivion. New visitors get no compelling reason to sign up before they're already scrolling past yesterday's products.
Your action plan
Ordered by conversion impact. Click any fix to see the before → after.
1
Replace dismissible welcome banner with persistent value-prop hero for logged-out users
▲ High ImpactSome WorkWelcome to Product Hunt! banner with Take a tour CTA
Currently
Thin dismissible banner: 'The place to launch and discover new tech products. Take a tour.'
Recommended
Persistent split hero for non-authenticated visitors: left side — 'Discover the best new tech products, every day' with Sign Up CTA; right side — today's top product count as social proof. Remove dismiss option.
Dismissible banners lose 60-80% of impressions within seconds. Logged-out visitors need a persistent conversion surface — this is the only above-fold signup prompt and it can vanish with one click.
2
Elevate and reposition the newsletter Sign Up CTA above the fold
▲ High ImpactQuick WinEmail signup strip buried between products 5 and 6
3
Add upvote-gating to prompt Sign In at moment of intent
▲ High ImpactQuick WinUpvote buttons (312, 228, 182) on product listings
4
Add quantified social proof to the nav Subscribe button
Medium ImpactQuick WinSubscribe button in top navigation
✎
Copy rewrites
Ready to useDrop-in replacements for your highest-leverage text. Each rewrite explains the conversion principle behind it.
Welcome banner headline
Welcome to Product Hunt!
→Discover the best new tech products — before everyone else does.
Specificity + FOMO: replaces a brand name restatement with a concrete benefit and early-adopter identity appeal.
Welcome banner subtext
The place to launch and discover new tech products.
→Every day, thousands of makers launch here first. Find what's next — or launch your own product to 500K+ tech enthusiasts.
Social proof + dual-audience messaging: speaks to both discoverers and launchers, adds scale credibility.
Newsletter signup strip
Get the best of Product Hunt, directly in your inbox.
→Join 500K+ makers and early adopters. Get today's top products delivered every morning — free.
Social proof + specificity + loss aversion: quantifies the community, sets delivery expectation, and removes cost objection.
Meta title
Product Hunt – The best new products in tech.
→Product Hunt – Discover Today's Best New Tech Products & Apps
SEO specificity: adds action verb, targets discovery intent, and includes 'Apps' for broader keyword coverage without losing brand clarity.
💡
The killer move
High ImpactImplement a personalized onboarding flow triggered by first scroll for logged-out users
After a visitor scrolls past 3 products (demonstrating intent), trigger a non-blocking slide-in: 'You have good taste. Create a free account to save products, get personalized picks, and upvote your favorites.' This converts the highest-intent moment — active browsing — into an account creation event, which is 4-6x more effective than cold nav CTAs.
How visitors experience your page
Second-by-second walkthrough.
1 strong2 mixed2 weak
◐
0-3 secondsMixed
0-3s First Impression: Orange logo, nav with 5 dropdowns, search bar, Subscribe + Sign In buttons, dismissible welcome banner, 'Top Products Launching Today' H1
Returning users feel at home immediately. New visitors see a familiar news-feed pattern but get no compelling reason to stay or sign up — the welcome banner reads as boilerplate and is easily dismissed.
✓
3-8 secondsStrong
3-8s Orientation: Ranked product list with upvote counts (312, 228, 182), category tags, founder avatars, Trending Forum Threads sidebar
The ranked list with social proof numbers (upvotes) immediately communicates value and credibility. Visitors understand the format instantly — this is the page's strongest conversion asset and it's doing its job.
◐
8-15 secondsMixed
8-15s Engagement: Products 3-5, newsletter signup strip between items 5 and 6, Framer ad banner
The newsletter CTA appears at a natural scroll pause but its plain styling makes it easy to skip. The Framer ad disrupts the product-browsing flow — visitors may feel the feed is monetized before they've formed loyalty.
✗
15-30 secondsWeak
15-30s Consideration: Products 6-11, 'See all of today's products' link, Yesterday's Top Products section beginning
No conversion prompt appears during this high-engagement window. Visitors are deep in content consumption with zero friction toward account creation — the page is giving away all its value with no ask.
✗
30+ secondsWeak
30s+ Decision: Yesterday's products, Last Week's, Last Month's, category grid, footer with newsletter signup
By this point, engaged visitors have consumed significant content with no personalization hook. The footer newsletter signup is the last conversion opportunity — most visitors will leave without any account or email relationship established.
Health check
8 dimensions, weighted by conversion impact.
First impression & hero
20%
5/10
Content-first layout serves returning users well but provides no compelling hook or conversion surface for new visitors above the fold.
Copy & messaging
20%
5/10
Product descriptions are functional but the site-level value proposition is buried in a dismissible banner with generic, unquantified language.
Call-to-action
15%
4/10
Sign In and Subscribe exist in the nav but no CTA is contextually placed at moments of peak engagement; newsletter signup is mid-scroll and easy to miss.
Trust & social proof
15%
7/10
Upvote counts, comment numbers, and ranked listings provide strong implicit social proof; explicit community size figures are absent from conversion surfaces.
Visual design & layout
10%
7/10
Clean, scannable two-column layout with consistent product card design; the Framer ad banner breaks visual rhythm but overall hierarchy is solid.
Page structure & flow
8%
6/10
Logical temporal structure (Today, Yesterday, Last Week, Last Month) aids discovery but conversion prompts are not integrated into the content flow strategically.
Technical & SEO signals
7%
7/10
PageSpeed 86 with LCP 2.0s and CLS 0.07 are solid; single H1 is appropriate but meta description could be more action-oriented for click-through improvement.
Differentiation & positioning
5%
5/10
Brand recognition carries the positioning load — the page itself never articulates why Product Hunt beats Reddit, Twitter, or newsletters for product discovery.
⚡
Based on real Chrome user dataPage speed
86/100
Overall score
Combined performance rating
2.0 s
Largest paint
Time until the main content is visible
0.07
Layout shift
How much the page moves while loading
1.7 s
First paint
Time until something first appears
86 ms
Responsiveness
How fast the page reacts to clicks
Want mobile analysis and fresh re-runs?
Buy roasts to unlock mobile analysis, re-analyze on demand, and more for producthunt.com.
See roast packs →