The Hick's Law shortcut
Hick's Law says decision time scales with the number of options. Two equal-weight CTAs are not twice as good — they're worse than one, because the visitor pauses to decide. The single most common pattern in pages we analyze that score below 50: three CTAs above the fold, all the same color, all the same prominence. The visitor processes them as a menu, not a recommendation, and clicks none.
The ladder of intent
Some visitors are ready to convert; most aren't. The right pattern: a primary CTA for the ready group ("Start free trial") and one secondary for the unready ("See how it works"). The secondary should be visually quieter — outlined button, ghost link, smaller size — so the primary is unambiguously the recommended action. Stripe and Linear nail this: the primary CTA pops, the secondary is a gentle alternative.
Repeating, not multiplying
Repeat the primary CTA at every natural pause: after the hero, after the social proof, after each objection-handling section, in a sticky bottom bar on mobile. Same copy, same color. Visitors decide at different points; meet them where they decide. Analyze your CTAs to see whether you're competing with yourself.